As a startup begins to gain traction and prepare for growth, one of the critical early leadership hires is bringing in strategic financial expertise. But what type of finance role should you prioritize - a fractional or part-time CFO, a full-time permanent CFO, or a VP of Finance? There are pros and cons to each approach depending on your startup's unique situation.
The case for hiring a Full-Time CFO
Bringing on a permanent, full-time Chief Financial Officer can be an excellent move once your startup reaches a certain level of maturity and scale. Here are some of the key benefits:
- Dedicated Strategic Leadership - A full-time CFO is fully embedded in the company as part of the executive team. They provide dedicated, C-suite leadership over all aspects of financial strategy, management, and growth initiatives.
- Seasoned Experience - You can attract experienced finance veterans who have been through multiple startup growth cycles. Their diverse experience is invaluable.
- Long-Term Partner - A great CFO can be a true long-term partner to the founder(s), helping navigate all the financial complexities of driving growth and value creation over many years.
The Argument for a Fractional/Part-Time CFO
Many early-stage startups choose to engage a fractional or part-time CFO before moving to a full-time hire. This approach offers several advantages:
- Flexibility & Lower Costs - You leverage top-tier CFO talent but only pay for the hours/time you truly need. This flexibility can be ideal in early stages with limited resources.
- Targeted Expertise - Fractional CFOs often have specialized subject matter expertise (e.g. fundraising, financial modeling, systems). You can bring in the exact skills you need most.
- Scalable Model - As your startup grows, you can scale up the fractional CFO's hours and responsibilities as an interim solution before hiring full-time.
The VP Finance Role
Before reaching the CFO stage, some startups hire a Vice President of Finance to oversee core finance/accounting operations like financial reporting, accounting, budgeting, forecasting, and payroll. While not quite at the strategic executive level of a CFO, a VP Finance can provide valuable operational finance leadership as a startup scales up. This is also a common option for startups who want to 'test out' a candidate before promoting them into the CFO role.
The Right Path Depends on Your Growth Stage
There's no one-size-fits-all answer for when a startup should hire a full-time CFO, engage a fractional CFO, or start with a VP Finance. It depends on factors like:
- Current company stage and growth trajectory
- Funding situation and financial resources
- Specific priorities (fundraising, financial modeling, systems implementation, etc.)
- Near-term goals and initiatives
In general, many early-stage startups first hire a VP Finance or fractional CFO before eventually "graduating" to hiring a permanent, full-time CFO once they've raised significant capital and reached a level of maturity that demands strategic executive finance leadership.
-
At Omna Search, we specialize in helping startups identify and attract the ideal financial leadership for their unique situation - whether that's an interim fractional CFO, a full-time permanent CFO, or an operational VP Finance role. If you'd like expert guidance on designing the right financial leadership strategy for your company's current growth stage, schedule a consultation with our team, or reach out to us at info@omnasearch.com.
